What qualifies as a promise?
A distinct, attributable public commitment with an identifiable intended outcome. General aspirations without a clear deliverable are not automatically scored as promises.
How do we assess delivery?
We record the original wording, who made the commitment, responsible institution, announced deadline if one exists, evidence of progress, and any changes to scope or responsibility.
Our status definitions
In progress: reliable evidence of meaningful work. Delivered: the defined outcome has been achieved. Partially delivered: some but not all elements achieved. Overdue: an actual published deadline has passed without full delivery. Abandoned: officially cancelled or withdrawn. Under review: insufficient verification for a final assessment.
Council reports versus independent verification
For Hume Council's 2025–26 annual actions, we separately record the Council's own reported classification (completed, ongoing or deferred). This describes what Council reports, not what The Promise Index has independently confirmed. A completed Council action does not necessarily establish that every underlying project or community outcome was delivered.
Independent verification requires evidence tied to the specific commitment and its scope. Until that is established, a Council-reported completion must not be counted as independently verified delivery. Automated source matching and progress signals are leads for review, not conclusive findings.
Fairness and corrections
The same rules apply to every party and government. We distinguish an announcing politician from the institution responsible for delivery, retain material revisions and give relevant institutions an opportunity to respond to significant adverse findings.
Before national rankings
We will prioritise reliable records and transparent counts. Any later comparative score will require a published methodology accounting for scope, complexity and attribution.
